Madison Institute Newsletter

1pixel.gif (807 bytes)Volume 2, Number 3
1pixel.gif (807 bytes)March, 2008

suffrage.jpg (33460 bytes)

We are put out of jail as we were put in jail—at the whim of the government. They tried to terrorize and suppress us. They could not, and so freed us. The administration has found that it dare not imprison American women for asking for a share in the democracy for which we are fighting. . . . [T]he arrests were unjust, arbitrary and gross discrimination made in an attempt to suppress legitimate propaganda, an attempt which failed.

-National Woman’s Party Press Release, November 27, 1917

In the fall of 1917 the US government jailed American woman suffragists for protesting against their lack of enfranchisement. They protested the fact that women had no say in government, and in particular, had no say in whether or not the country went to war. They were astounded at the harsh treatment they received at the hands of prison guards and were radicalized by the knowledge that the American government was not about justice, fairness or democracy during those early 20th century war years. Fast forward a century, and Americans who protest against a lack of fairness, justice and democracy, are again oppressed by the American government. Now, as then, ours is a government which is unmoved by appeals to the rule of law or to the people’s right to a voice, particularly when that voice is raised to protest violence, unjust war, and the establishing of empire and armies of occupation. In 1917 there was racist prejudice against African-Americans, German and Italian-Americans, and intolerance of leftist and feminist activists. And now the same holds true with the omission of Germans and Italians. Just add a rabid anti-Muslim prejudice, which is getting worse all the time. Our featured guest writer has been active in the fight to combat injustice for years – a fight which has included government-sponsored jailtime. His story is engrossing and must be read by anyone concerned with preserving any modicum of the rule of law in this country. It is evident that people concerned with the attainment of justice, whether women without representation, or citizens who are losing representation, must continue to protest.

At our last MIPP meeting, we also addressed issues of fairness and injustice. We showed two excellent films for our mini-Palestinian/Israeli film festival: “West Bank Story” and “Paradise Lost.” They provided an excellent contrast of ways of looking at Israeli-Palestinian relations. The first provoked much delighted laughter while making its point of the insanity of two peoples not able to live together, paralleling the lack of toleration portrayed in “West Side Story.” The other was a very serious, thoughtful portrayal of a young woman struggling to understand the resistance and accommodation of the Palestinian people as she studies her village, friends, and family all living under long-term Israeli occupation. We had some great Middle Eastern food and some equally great discussion. Another excellent meeting.

Really good news! A man who has always been devoted to the good fight is running for president. My man Ralph Nader has bravely launched a campaign which will bring him no end of criticism and condemnation for daring to hold up the two-party system to the light to show it for the empty shell that it is. Mr. Nader has no problem telling it like it is—and it’s not good. He has statistics, stories, and convincing arguments to explain to us why our economy is in tatters, why our foreign policy is utterly wrong, why this culture is in such dire straits. AND he does have solutions, all of which involve restoring democracy and common decency in this country. Senators Obama and Clinton’s wars continue. But is there really any difference between them? It’s hard to say—e.g., Obama apparently was negative about NAFTA, and when Canada took offense, his people had to explain to Canada that he only said that to get elected. What exactly are his ideals and principles?  Obama is horrified to be “smeared” by the Clinton people who showed a photo of him in Muslim-like robes. Horrors! Is it so terrible to be called Muslim? And this from a black man? And who can take seriously—as a feminist—the candidacy of Hillary Clinton, which is so incredibly contrived and parsed and adjusted from day to day? This is not a flesh-and-blood woman. She is just a front for those who actually pull the strings—just like George W. Add McCain and his promises of a 100-year war to maintain America’s “honor” and you thank God for Ralph Nader.
It’s interesting how all the presidential candidates talk about “what I’ll do” as president, as if they were solitary dictators without Congress, Courts, media or the public. Well, I guess that is what the situation has become under this administration.

The Gaza Bombshell... "Vanity Fair has obtained confidential documents... which lay bare a covert initiative, approved by Bush and implemented by... Rice... to provoke a Palestinian civil war.   The plan was for forces armed with new weapons supplied at America's behest, to give Fatah the muscle to remove the democratically elected Hamas-led goverment..."

David Rose, Vanity Fair, March 3, 2008  (Story link)

Representing Maasoum Abdah Mouhammad
Protesting the Guantanamo Concentration Camp At the Supreme Court

By Ed Kinane

On January 11, 2007, the fifth anniversary of the opening of the U.S. concentration camp at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, dozens of us solemnly assembled inside Federal District Court in Washington, DC. Organized by Witness Against Torture, we were exercising our First Amendment right of free assembly and we were petitioning our government for redress of grievances.

While we were allowed to begin a liturgical program in the court building, that program wasxray1.jpg (21225 bytes) interrupted and we were arrested for refusing to remove our bright orange Close Guantanamo T-shirts. (Shouldn’t T-shirt slogans be protected speech?) Just outside the court building that day many other peaceful demonstrators, some in orange jump suits, were also arrested.

Most of us arrested didn’t give our real names or provide photo ID. Instead we declared, “I am representing Guantanamo prisoner [name].” The Gitmo prisoner I represented was Maasoum Abdah Mouhammad. According to the Wikipedia, Mouhammad is an ethnic Kurd born in 1972 in Qameshle, Syria. He allegedly was a Taliban member. His detainee number is 330.

We were booked, charged with disorderly conduct, and released hours later. My citation had me as “John Doe #33.” Our cases were eventually dismissed; Mouhammad remains in judicial detention.

U.S. Supreme Court – One Year Later

This year on January 11, a Friday, Witness Against Torture again held a mass protest against Guantanamo – this time inside and outside of the U.S. Supreme Court. Long-time DC activists couldn’t recall when there had ever been a mass protest inside the august Supreme Court building....  (For complete article)

 


Before The Law

Syracuse native and  resident, Ed Kinane, and the members of the organization Witness Against Torture are not the only people speaking out on behalf of those imprisoned during the American “Global War on Terror.”

Nicholas D. Kristof wrote that Sami al-Hajj, a former Al Jazeera cameraman, who is currently on a hunger strike in Guantanamo Bay, is being force-fed by his American captors. Kristof states, al-Hajj who was arrested in December 2001 in Afghanistan, “was beaten, starved, frozen and subjected to anal searches in public to humiliate him, according to his lawyers.”

Initially, according to Kristof, the US mistook him for another cameraman and upon discovering their mistake, made “vague accusations” against him, accusing Mr. Hajj of assisting extremist groups. His lawyers claim that al-Hajj was offered, but refused, a deal immediately upon his capture, in which he would be granted freedom in exchange for spying on Al Jazeera.

Kristof reports that according to American military officials, Mr. Hajj would have been released if he had “come clean.” The New York Times writer calls the situation at Guantanamo Kafkaesque, but this seems at least as reminiscent of the Salem witch trials. There, women who admitted that they were witches were freed, while those that denied the charges against them faced the ultimate punishment.  (see “When We Torture,” NY Times, February 14)

A petition calling for the release of Sami al-Hajj, detainee number 345, plus additional information on the imprisoned journalist can be found at the Reporters Without Borders site.  A statement from Mr. Hajj can be found in this summary of the Administrative Review Board Proceedings, p.122, which is at the US Department of Defense web site. 

Closer to home, Denis Halliday, former Assistant Secretary-General at the United Nations, wrote a letter to the Syracuse Post-Standard in support of the imprisoned Manlius oncologist, Rafil Dhafir. In that letter Halliday asks, “Dr. Dhafir has become a victim of American injustice that applies double standards. He has been swept up in anti-Islamic, anti-Arab madness that has corrupted the American justice system. It is past time that all humanitarian-minded, decent Americans ask ourselves: Is this the justice system that we want?”

On February 8, 2008, Rafil Dhafir’s lawyers formally appealed the judgment against the Manilius doctor, who is currently serving a 22-year sentence in Federal prison. Dr. Dhafir, who was born in Iraq, but is a long-time US citizen, operated a charity (Help the Needy) which provided aid to poor Iraqis, who were the most helpless victims of US sanctions. The Manilius, NY doctor was convicted of illegal money transfers to Iraq in violation of United States law (the Iraq Sanction policy), money-laundering, Medicare fraud, income tax evasion and defrauding donors. Dr. Dhafir and his supporters claim that these charges stem from the mistaken belief of US officials that the Manlius doctor funded terrorism.

The fact that the US Justice Department regarded Dhafir as a supporter of terrorism is evidenced by a number of statements by government officials, among them then Governor of New York, George Pataki. Dr. Dhafir was never formally charged with any terrorism-related crimes.

The first argument made in the appeal is that “[t]he trial court improperly prohibited cross-examination that would have demonstrated the government’s bias against Dr. Dhafir based on its initial, but mistaken and ultimately fruitless, investigation of Dr. Dhafir as a suspected supporter of terrorism.” The full brief is available here. A full history of the Dhafir case, as well as updates is available at Katherine Hughes’ site, dhafirtrail.net.

Nicholas Kristof says that the Bush administration claims that the prisoners incarcerated in Guantanamo are the “worst of the worst,” but evidence reveals that they are just the “unluckiest of the unluckiest.” It seems that this may also be said about Dr. Dhafir. --IG


Detainee:  I have been in jail for three years....  Nobody has told me the reason I am here.  Everybody asks me, but nobody tells me why.  Everybody gives me orders and blame.  I am a human being.  I have also the right to find out about all these things.  Nobody is ready to tell me who I can ask about this.  I need the answer for this.

Tribunal President: I can tell you that we've given you all the information we can; the Administrative Review Board process will give you additional information.

Detainee:  When will that be approximately?

Tribunal President: To be honest, I don't know what the date is.

Detainee:  ...I am an oppressed person, and I am just like the homeless people going from one place to the other.  For three years, I went from one place to the other like a homeless person, and no one is telling me why this is happening to me.   My family and my everything is distressed.  I have a right to survive in the world.

Tribunal President:  Your opinions or comments are noted for the record.

An unidentified detainee appearing before the Combatant Status Review Tribunal, Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, date unknown.  Source:  Defense Department website, transcript of the proceedings, pps. 87, 88.

 

The next MIPP meeting will be held on Tuesday  March 18 at 7:00 pm at Half Moon Books in Madison.

We'll be turning away from film to do what will most definitely be a lively session - it'll be "Potluck and Politics" - dinner and a political discussion.  In order to participate, everyone who comes will be asked to bring a dish to pass, so if you would like to attend, please contact Linda as indicated below.

In April, we are scheduling an ERA talk with Linda Ford, the author of Iron-Jawed Angels and yours truly.

For information, please contact Linda at lford@toast2.net or 315 893 7577.

See you there!

Coming Events

Vigil on Hamilton Village Green
Chenango Valley Peace Alliance
Saturday, March 15, 12 Noon - 1 pm

Stand in witness to the 5th
anniversary of the Iraq War.
 

Bring signs and friends
---All are welcome---

Weekly Peace Outreach, Syracuse
Stop the War In Iraq!
Tuesdays in March, 4:30 - 5:15 pm

March 11 - Geddes St. and West Genessee
1pixel.gif (807 bytes)(Westside)
March 18 - Teall Ave and Rt. 690 (Eastside)

March 25 - Rt. 11(in front of Northern Lights)
1pixel.gif (807 bytes)(Mattydale)

(See Syracuse Peace Council Events
Calendar
for details.)

Jeremy Scahill Lecture

Tuesday, April 1, 7 pm
Panasci Family Chapel
Le Moyne College, Syracuse

Mr. Scahill will talk about his recent book, Blackwater:   The Rise of the Worlds Most Powerful Mercenary Army.

The Dalai Lama Visits Hamilton
Latest information as of March 10
Tuesday, April 22
Details to be arranged
Colgate University, Hamilton

All events are free and open to
the public unless otherwise noted.

 


To subscribe to this newsletter email lford[at]toast[dot]net.   Type "subscribe newsletter" as subject.

To unsubscribe to this newsletter email lford[at]toast[dot]net.   Type "unsubscribe newsletter" as subject.

Previous newsletters
Volume 1, Number 1
Volume 1, Number 2
Volume 2, Number 1
Volume 2, Number 2

Submitted by Linda Ford